The Pie Shed · Nappanee, Indiana

Good days start with something homemade.

Stop by for cinnamon rolls, cakes, pies and whatever sweet surprise is fresh that day. Pick your favorite, pay on the honor system, and take a little comfort home.

ORDER Plan a visit

Wed–Sat8 AM–6 PM

Worth the drive26150 County Road 50

A case full of reasons to stop.

The selection changes with the bake. These are the treats locals mention again and again—come early if you have your heart set on something.

Best Seller

Cinnamon rolls

Soft spirals with generous icing—the kind of breakfast that never waits until breakfast.

Best Seller

Lemon raspberry cake

Bright, berry-sweet layers made for sharing. Or not.

Apple crisp

Warm spice, tender fruit and a golden crumble.

Fudge cake

Deep chocolate comfort by the slice.

Caramel cake

Buttery cake under a rich caramel finish.

Bring something homemade to the table.

Planning a birthday, holiday table or big family breakfast? Call to ask about cakes, pies, cinnamon rolls and current special-order availability.

ORDER BY PHONE

Make the sweet little detour.

Wednesday: 8 AM–6 PM
Thursday: 8 AM–6 PM
Friday: 8 AM–6 PM
Saturday: 8 AM–6 PM

Get directions →

Find us

26150 County Road 50
Nappanee, IN 46550

Call ahead

Looking for a particular cake or treat? Call (574) 773-8967 before you make the trip.

How payment works

The Pie Shed operates on the honor system and accepts cash, personal checks and Venmo.

Stock lifestyle image for this unofficial demo.

The story behind the shed.

This is a small, local stop with a rotating bake and a simple way of doing business. Walk in, see what’s fresh, choose your treats and settle up on the honor system.

It’s the kind of place that makes a County Road 50 detour feel personal: a sweet treat, a little trust and something homemade to take with you.

Follow along for the latest bakes and seasonal favorites.

See The Pie Shed on Instagram →